Mafia: The Old Country Review – A Mob Story Worthy of Cinema, Not a Shootout

The Mafia franchise from 2K Games represents the pinnacle of organized crime storytelling in gaming, delivering experiences that satisfy the deepest cravings for underworld drama. As we explore Mafia: The Old Country, it’s important to understand my deep appreciation for the series’ commitment to straightforward, compelling narrative techniques.

My introduction to this world started with Mafia 2 back in 2010. What began as casual curiosity quickly transformed into genuine obsession. The carefully curated soundtrack, the meticulously crafted winter environments, each mission unfolding like sequences from legendary gangster cinema. Completing the initial playthrough only fueled my desire for more—I immediately sought out the original title, then eagerly awaited Mafia 3’s release. Having experienced the complete trilogy, I became thoroughly captivated by its raw authenticity and masterful story construction.

When 2K announced Mafia: The Old Country, anticipation surged for this drama-rich experience reminiscent of Peaky Blinders’ intensity. After investing approximately 15 hours to reach completion, The Old Country genuinely recaptured the magic that originally drew me to the series. Crucially, the overly ambitious open-world design that hampered Mafia 3 has been eliminated, returning to the focused approach that defined the franchise’s beginnings.

Firearm engagements occur less frequently and adopt a more deliberate pace in this newest Mafia chapter. The interactive experience prioritizes atmospheric tension over constant action. However, the richly developed characters, immersive environments, and exceptional writing maintain player engagement with the intensity of high-stakes negotiations between competing crime families (and occasionally within your own organization). In this environment, one element dominates above all others—narrative craftsmanship.

For players transitioning from more action-heavy titles like Battlefield 6, the adjustment to this methodical pacing requires significant mindset shifts. Common mistakes include approaching situations with run-and-gun mentalities when strategic positioning and environmental awareness prove far more effective. Advanced players should focus on dialogue cues and character interactions, as these often provide critical tactical advantages.

The narrative of Mafia: The Old Country unfolds in early 20th-century Sicily, a region steeped in violent heritage and cultural richness. Players assume the role of Enzo Favara, a child betrayed through paternal sale at just five years old. This childhood trauma created an enduring void in his emotional development, simultaneously planting seeds of vengeance—a burning need to confront his biological father should fate ever grant the opportunity.

Contrary to expectations, this isn’t merely another simplistic paternal vengeance narrative driven by ambition. The father-figure dynamic serves as a central thematic pillar, establishing profound emotional connections with Enzo’s character development. Interestingly, the climactic father-son confrontation occurs with an unexpected character, elevating the thematic complexity and dramatic impact. This narrative choice proves effective as the storyline avoids excessive origin exposition, instead launching directly into the primary narrative where our gameplay experience commences.

Our journey properly begins years later, within the oppressive sulfur mines controlled by the Spadaro crime family, where Enzo endures endless labor cycles rewarded only with poverty and deteriorating health. There, he abandons a modest wooden keepsake from his father, intricately engraved with his identity. Driven by unwavering determination, Enzo pursues a singular objective above all else—earned dignity.

In the Old Country’s social hierarchy, respect represents a currency that must be legitimately obtained. However, Sicilian respect transactions demand absolute allegiance and, when necessary, violent sacrifice—the environment where we encounter Don Bernardo Torrisi.

Understanding character progression systems becomes crucial here, much like mastering class specializations in tactical shooters. Players should allocate approximately 6-8 hours to fully develop Enzo’s core relationships, as rushing these interactions significantly diminishes emotional payoff.

Don Torrisi functions as the narrative’s central axis, with the plot executing a substantial directional shift at a pivotal moment (no spoilers here). Before examining his influence on Enzo’s trajectory, we must acknowledge the exceptional vocal performance behind the character.

Yes, this element deserves special recognition. The casting throughout the new Mafia installment demonstrates remarkable quality across all roles, but John Santiago’s contribution establishes an entirely new benchmark.

As the English vocal artist for Bernardo Torrisi, his raw, resonant delivery penetrates directly to the emotional core. This represents the caliber of performance that immediately evokes memories of The Godfather, carrying distinct echoes of Marlon Brando’s iconic portrayal of Vito Corleone. Timeless. The undisputed ruler of criminal enterprises. Don Torrisi’s actions consistently validate the ominous atmosphere and vocal intensity. This relationship provides Enzo with the paternal guidance missing from his formative years.

Much like optimizing weapon loadouts in combat-focused games, understanding when to leverage Torrisi’s influence versus pursuing independent action creates meaningful strategic depth. Advanced players should note that key decisions affecting the father-son dynamic become irreversible after Chapter 7, requiring careful consideration of long-term consequences.

The vehicle mechanics in Mafia: The Old Country authentically capture 1900s Sicilian transportation. Automobiles feature realistic wooden wheel clattering, chain rattling sounds, and period-accurate gramophone skipping during aggressive driving. The horseback riding experience closely mirrors Red Dead Redemption 2’s fluidity, creating occasional genre confusion given both titles share the 2K publishing umbrella. Unfortunately, there aren’t many chase sequences integrated into the core gameplay, representing a significant missed opportunity for dynamic vehicular action. A handful of side missions focused around vehicle mechanics could have substantially enhanced the gameplay loop’s excitement. The exploration aspect remains limited, as the title deliberately avoids traditional open-world design in favor of a more structured experience.

For players seeking to maximize their transportation experience, consider these strategic approaches: First, experiment with different driving styles to discover hidden audio cues and environmental interactions. Second, utilize horseback routes for scenic paths that often contain subtle narrative details. Third, recognize that fast travel options exist but may bypass unique atmospheric elements that enrich the game’s historical setting.

You’ll frequently encounter NPCs stuck in random scripted routines that break immersion, while enemy combatants often charge directly toward your position with minimal tactical awareness, making them easy targets for shotgun blasts. While adversaries aren’t intellectual powerhouses, they demonstrate sufficient awareness to avoid being completely predictable. When engaging with higher difficulty settings, even a stray bullet can end your day, compelling players to adopt hitman-like precision rather than soldier-style frontal assaults. For those craving intense, adrenaline-fueled encounters, elevated difficulty modes provide that thrilling ride sensation.

However, an inexplicable design choice disables controller aim assist to artificially increase challenge, creating accessibility concerns for players relying on these input methods. To optimize your combat effectiveness, master these techniques: Prioritize cover positioning before engaging, use environmental distractions to manipulate enemy movements, and conserve ammunition for critical encounters. Understanding enemy spawn patterns can also give you strategic advantages in challenging firefights.

Certain environments evoke Uncharted’s adventurous spirit through straightforward puzzle mechanics and basic platforming elements. The absence of a minimap may frustrate navigation-challenged players who depend heavily on waypoint markers. Puzzle complexity remains minimal throughout, comparable to reading hastily scribbled notes from a visible sticky note. Some secured doors and locked containers require passcodes, but these solutions typically reside immediately adjacent to their corresponding puzzles, as if the challenges couldn’t be bothered with concealment.

While recognizing this isn’t a dedicated treasure hunting experience, the lack of escalating difficulty feels particularly noticeable during mob rank progression sequences where increased complexity would better reflect narrative advancement. For optimal puzzle navigation: Always scan the immediate vicinity for clues before moving forward, document recurring puzzle patterns for future reference, and utilize the objective marker system when environmental navigation becomes challenging.

Traversing The Old Country’s landscapes often feels reminiscent of a 2017-era Red Dead Redemption 2—both visually and aesthetically. While the historical period recreation represents an appropriate creative decision, I anticipated Mafia would maintain stronger franchise identity rather than emulating other successful titles. Fortunately, equestrian segments remain minimal if players choose to bypass optional riding content. Both automobile and horseback travel sections can be skipped entirely for rapid destination arrival.

The artistic direction successfully transports players to early 20th century Sicily, though the visual similarity to other period pieces occasionally diminishes the game’s unique character. Players should consider balancing skipped travel with occasional immersive journeys to fully appreciate the environmental storytelling and atmospheric design.

Overall, gameplay mechanics don’t represent Mafia: The Old Country’s primary attraction. While featuring character charm progression systems and weapon unlocking mechanics, the narrative-first design philosophy means many combat scenarios transition into cinematic sequences. Primary missions alternate between intense firefights, surveillance operations, and occasional stealth infiltration scenarios.

Not every assignment achieves consistent quality standards, but the standout missions feel like they were written with a cigar in one hand and a shotgun in the other. When mission pacing achieves synchronization, the experience becomes pure organized crime cinema in interactive form. I recommend tempering expectations regarding revolutionary gameplay systems comparable to Red Dead Redemption 2. A more accurate comparison would be a humanized interpretation of Assassin’s Creed: Brotherhood’s Da Vinci quests with enhanced cinematic elements.

The complete playthrough remains relatively brief, approximately 14 hours including cinematic sequences. However, the universal disappointment concerns performance issues and polishing deficiencies that impact the overall experience.

Contemporary AAA titles in 2025 frequently share performance complications, and Mafia: The Old Country continues this troubling trend. The game periodically runs poorly with performance degradation that feels intentionally obstructive. Even utilizing medium or low graphical configurations, consistent frame rates remain an unattainable ideal. Specific sequences seem engineered for stuttering, particularly during transitions between gameplay and cinematic segments. The experience parallels operating software on outdated Pentium processors with integrated Intel graphics. These technical issues occur with such regularity that players develop anticipatory expectations.

Restricted configuration options exacerbate these problems. PlayStation 5 versions feature frame rate caps yet still deliver choppy performance. PC editions prevent adjustment of certain visual settings like lighting or foliage density, as though these modifications would transform Sicily into a futuristic Night City equivalent. Spoiler alert: they won’t. The visual presentation maintains somewhat dated aesthetics despite demanding hardware requirements. Even employing premium components like R7 9800X3D processors paired with 5060Ti graphics cards, the game barely scrapes past 50 FPS on average, indicating significant optimization deficiencies.

For performance optimization: First, prioritize driver updates before launching. Second, experiment with resolution scaling rather than preset adjustments. Third, monitor background applications that might consume unnecessary system resources during gameplay sessions.

While Mafia: The Old Country may not achieve perfection in every aspect, it carves out a distinctive place in the gaming landscape through its masterful narrative execution. The game particularly resonates with players who appreciate deep emotional storytelling and character-driven experiences. Enzo’s transformation from street-level operative to organized crime figurehead provides a compelling arc that mirrors classic mob cinema.

The intricate web of relationships within the Torrisi family creates genuine tension, where every alliance feels fragile and every betrayal carries weight. These slow-burning narrative threads culminate in moments that will stick with players long after the credits roll. The game’s ability to make you care about these morally complex characters represents its greatest achievement.

Where The Old Country struggles is in its moment-to-moment gameplay execution. The combat systems feel dated compared to contemporary action titles, lacking the fluidity and responsiveness that modern gamers expect. Mission design often follows predictable patterns that can become repetitive over extended play sessions.

Performance issues present significant obstacles to immersion, with frame rate drops, texture pop-in, and occasional crashes disrupting the carefully crafted atmosphere. These technical shortcomings may prove particularly frustrating for players accustomed to polished gaming experiences. For those seeking refined gameplay mechanics, titles like our BF6 Weapons Unlock guide demonstrates the level of polish available in other modern games.

Common mistakes include approaching combat too aggressively – the game rewards tactical positioning and patience over run-and-gun approaches. Optimization tips include lowering shadow quality and disabling motion blur to improve stability during intense sequences.

The Old Country represents a deliberate return to the foundational elements that established the Mafia series as a storytelling powerhouse. It captures the gritty authenticity, period-accurate style, and tragic undertones that defined the franchise’s most memorable entries. This commitment to series identity will particularly satisfy long-time fans who felt recent installments strayed from core principles.

This installment serves a specific audience segment – players who prioritize narrative depth over mechanical innovation. If your primary interest lies in cinematic storytelling and character development, The Old Country delivers an experience reminiscent of premium television drama. As explored in our Class Guide, different games excel at different aspects of the gaming experience.

Time estimates for completing the main story range from 12-15 hours, with additional 5-7 hours for side content. The game’s pacing allows character relationships to develop naturally, though some players may find the slower moments test their patience. Understanding these pacing decisions is crucial to appreciating what the developers aimed to achieve, much like the strategic planning required in our Complete Guide to Battlefield 6.

No reproduction without permission：Tsp Game Club » Mafia: The Old Country Review – A Mob Story Worthy of Cinema, Not a Shootout